Why a long-term rental can be a more stable investment than a short-term let

Why a long-term rental can be a more stable investment than a short-term let.

Why Long-Term Rentals Offer Superior Stability for Arequipa Real Estate Investors

As a licensed Peruvian real estate broker specializing in Arequipa, I frequently encounter foreign investors intrigued by the potential of the local market. The allure of short-term vacation rentals, with their seemingly higher nightly rates, often captures initial attention. However, for investors prioritizing long-term financial stability, reduced operational burden, and a smoother legal pathway in Peru, the traditional long-term residential rental offers a profoundly more robust and predictable investment strategy. This article will delve into the practical and legal advantages, guiding you through the essential considerations for successful long-term property investment in Arequipa.

Understanding Arequipa's Investment Landscape

Arequipa, with its stunning colonial architecture, vibrant culture, and growing economy fueled by sectors like mining, agro-exports, and tourism, attracts both tourists and a significant expat community. While the tourist sector provides a niche for short-term lets, the city's expanding universities (such as UNSA, UCSM, and UTP), burgeoning professional class, and appeal to foreign residents create a strong, consistent demand for quality long-term housing. Neighborhoods such as Yanahuara, Cayma, Selva Alegre, Miraflores, and certain well-regarded areas within the Cercado (Arequipa's historic center, with careful consideration for historic property regulations) are particularly sought after for long-term residential leases, offering excellent stability and appreciation potential.

The Core Advantages of Long-Term Rentals

1. Predictable and Consistent Income Stream

The primary benefit of a long-term rental is the stability of its income. Unlike short-term lets, which are subject to seasonal fluctuations, economic downturns affecting tourism, and intense competition, a long-term lease agreement (typically 1 to 3 years in Peru) secures a consistent monthly rental payment. This predictability allows for more accurate financial forecasting, easier budgeting, and a reduced risk of prolonged vacancies, making your investment a reliable asset rather than a variable gamble.

2. Lower Operational Costs and Reduced Management Burden

The ongoing costs and time commitment associated with property management are significantly lower for long-term rentals:

  • Fewer Cleaning and Maintenance Cycles: Short-term rentals necessitate professional cleaning services, frequent linen changes, and constant restocking of amenities after every guest. Long-term tenants are responsible for daily upkeep, dramatically reducing your expenses and effort.
  • Reduced Marketing and Booking Efforts: Securing a long-term tenant means avoiding the continuous cycle of marketing, listing management, guest communication, and booking platform fees inherent in short-term rentals. This translates to substantial savings in time, money, and administrative headaches.
  • Lower Utility Fluctuation Risk: In the vast majority of long-term residential leases in Peru, tenants are directly responsible for utility payments (electricity, water, gas, internet). This standard arrangement eliminates the investor's exposure to fluctuating utility costs, a common variable in short-term rentals where utilities are often included or absorbed by the owner.

3. Enhanced Property Condition & Tenant Responsibility

Tenants who commit to a long-term lease often develop a greater sense of responsibility for the property. They treat it more like their own home, leading to less wear and tear compared to the transient nature of short-term guests. Peruvian lease agreements clearly delineate responsibilities for minor repairs and general maintenance (e.g., light bulbs are typically tenant's, major appliance repairs are landlord's), further safeguarding your asset. A standard security deposit (typically 1-2 months' rent) also provides a financial buffer against potential damages, to be returned at the end of the lease, less any approved deductions for damages beyond normal wear and tear.

4. Simplified Legal and Tax Compliance (Peruvian Context)

Navigating Peruvian bureaucracy can be complex for foreign investors. Long-term residential rentals generally offer a more straightforward path regarding legal and tax compliance:

  • Rental Contracts (Contrato de Arrendamiento): For long-term residential leases, a standard Contrato de Arrendamiento is used. This contract *must be drafted by a qualified Peruvian lawyer and signed before a Notary Public (Notario Público). Notarization grants the contract fecha cierta (certain date) and strong legal enforceability, particularly crucial for expedited eviction proceedings. An un-notarized contract offers significantly less protection.
  • Taxation (Impuesto a la Renta - Renta de Capital): For individuals renting out residential property long-term, Peru offers a simplified tax regime. You are generally subject to a monthly 5% tax on the gross rental income (pursuant to Article 23 of the Peruvian Income Tax Law, Ley del Impuesto a la Renta). This is a straightforward calculation and payment process, often less complex than the tax implications for short-term rentals, which might be classified as business income requiring different tax regimes (e.g., Régimen Especial de Renta or Régimen MYPE Tributario), depending on the volume of activity and services provided. It is essential to issue formal receipts (Recibos por Arrendamiento) for each payment, which can be done easily online via SUNAT.
  • Tourist Licensing: Short-term rentals often require specific permits from the local municipality and the Ministry of Foreign Trade and Tourism (MINCETUR), adding layers of cost, inspection, and ongoing compliance. Long-term residential rentals are exempt from these specific tourist licenses, simplifying your operational framework.

Mitigating Risks in Long-Term Rentals

While more stable, long-term rentals still require diligent management to minimize risks.

1. Due Diligence on Tenants: A Crucial Safety Check

Thorough tenant screening is paramount. Do not rush this step. Step-by-Step Tenant Vetting:

  1. Income Verification: Request proof of stable employment and sufficient income (e.g., recent pay stubs, bank statements, employment letters). A common guideline is to ensure the tenant's gross income is at least three times the monthly rent.
  2. Credit Check: While not as comprehensive as in some countries, local credit bureaus like Infocorp can provide financial history. Requesting previous landlord references is also crucial to ascertain payment habits and care for property.
  3. Identity Verification: Always obtain and verify a copy of the tenant's official identification (Documento Nacional de Identidad - DNI for Peruvians, Carné de Extranjería for foreign residents).
  4. Personal Interview: Conduct an in-person interview to assess suitability, reliability, and ensure a good fit for your property.

2. The Indispensable Role of a Solid Rental Contract

A robust Contrato de Arrendamiento is your primary legal protection. Key Contract Elements and Safety Checks:

  1. Professional Drafting: Insist on a lawyer-drafted contract tailored specifically to Peruvian law.
  2. Notarization: Always sign the contract before a Peruvian Notary Public. This is non-negotiable for legal enforceability, as it certifies the identities of the signatories and the date of the agreement.
  3. Clear Clauses: Ensure the contract explicitly details:
    • Rental amount, payment due date, and penalties for late payment.
    • Security deposit amount (typically 1-2 months' rent) and precise conditions for its return (e.g., property left in same condition, less normal wear and tear, all utilities paid).
    • Lease duration (e.g., 1 year renewable) and conditions for early termination by either party.
    • Tenant and landlord responsibilities for maintenance and utilities.
    • An "Allanamiento Futuro" (Future Foreclosure) clause: This critical clause (backed by Laws No. 30201 and 30911) allows for expedited eviction in cases of non-payment or expiration of the lease, significantly reducing the typical delays in Peruvian eviction processes. This clause must be explicitly included and signed off by the tenant before a Notary Public to be effective.
    • A detailed inventory list of any furnished items, along with their condition, signed by both parties at the commencement of the lease.

3. S.U.N.A.R.P. Registration: An Added Layer of Security

While not strictly mandatory for residential leases, registering your notarized lease agreement with S.U.N.A.R.P. (National Superintendence of Public Registries) in the Registro de Predios (Property Registry) provides an additional layer of legal security. This public registration makes the lease binding against third parties and further strengthens the landlord's position in case of disputes or challenges to ownership, offering superior transparency and legal standing.

4. Property Management Options for Foreign Investors

For foreign investors living abroad or unfamiliar with local practices, engaging a reputable local property management company is highly recommended. They can competently handle tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, legal compliance, and manage tenant relations, providing peace of mind and ensuring your investment runs smoothly and profitably.

Local Context/Warning Section

  • Notarization is Non-Negotiable: For any significant property transaction or long-term lease in Peru, including the Contrato de Arrendamiento, notarization by a Notario Público is absolutely essential. Un-notarized contracts have significantly weaker legal standing and can complicate dispute resolution, often leaving the landlord at a severe disadvantage.
  • Eviction Process (Proceso de Desalojo): Despite improvements in Peruvian law, the eviction process can still be lengthy if not properly initiated. The "Allanamiento Futuro" clause in your notarized contract is your most potent tool for an expedited process. Without it, evicting a non-paying or overstaying tenant can regrettably take many months, if not years, through the standard judicial system.
  • Historic Properties in Arequipa's Centro Histórico: If you are considering properties within Arequipa's UNESCO World Heritage zone, be aware that strict regulations from the Ministerio de Cultura and the local municipality apply. These rules govern renovations, permitted uses, and even architectural aesthetics. While long-term residential use is generally supported, any significant modifications will require extensive permits and adherence to specific heritage conservation guidelines. Due diligence on such properties is crucial.
  • Currency Fluctuations: While most long-term rents in Arequipa are typically denominated in Peruvian Soles (PEN), some high-end properties, especially those marketed to expats, may quote in USD. Be mindful of potential currency exchange rate risks if your income or expenses are primarily in a different currency. (As a general reference, 1 USD is approximately 3.70 PEN as of early 2024, but this fluctuates with market conditions).

Conclusion

For the discerning investor in Arequipa's dynamic real estate market, a long-term residential rental strategy offers a superior blend of stability, predictability, and reduced operational complexity compared to short-term lets. By focusing on diligent tenant screening, employing legally sound, notarized contracts with key protective clauses like "Allanamiento Futuro," and understanding the local regulatory environment, foreign investors can build a resilient and profitable portfolio in the beautiful White City. While the immediate allure of higher nightly rates from short-term rentals can be tempting, the long-term view unequivocally favors the consistent returns and peace of mind provided by a well-managed, long-term rental property.


⚠️ Legal Notice: Consult a Local Lawyer. The information provided in this article is for general guidance and informational purposes only, and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Real estate laws and regulations in Peru are complex and subject to change. It is imperative that all foreign investors consult with a qualified Peruvian real estate attorney and tax advisor before making any investment decisions.


Ready to explore long-term rental opportunities in Arequipa? Visit ArequipaRealEstate.com to browse our curated listings and connect with expert local advisors.